闲云野鹤：时光隧道: A DEFENDER OF CHINA

引用 2011-3-2 12:07 AM

谢谢野鹤和漫人，好看。

引用 2011-3-1 11:50 AM

闲云野鹤: 接着漫人提到的台儿庄后面，作者写道：

These Atrocities Explain Jap Defeat

These ten pictures are not pretty to look at, but they partially explain wh ...

明白了！谢谢你和漫人！

引用 2011-3-1 10:44 AM

闲云野鹤: 接着漫人提到的台儿庄后面，作者写道：

These Atrocities Explain Jap Defeat

These ten pictures are not pretty to look at, but they partially explain wh ...

是的，同仇敌忾，众志成城，我想，是这篇报道要表达的主题。但血肉长城付出的代价是巨大的，需要的也不光是勇气和决心。

野鹤兄也提到了，这里也由南京大屠杀的相关报道，有文字，有图片。虽然没有整体的统计数据，但是有涉及到家庭灾难的数字。至于真相，恐怕是各人心中的浮云了。

至于国共，或者是八路还是七路，对美国人来说没有什么区别。在他们眼里，就是中国有了抵抗力量，而且不光是军队，更是敌后的农民百姓。

我觉得这一系列的报道还是相当正面的。有兴趣的也可以到这里看看：
http://books.google.com/books?id=20oEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA2&dq=may+16+1938+life+magazine&hl=en&ei=xxNtTaHALtL1gAebveyZBA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=book-preview-link&resnum=2&ved=0CEAQuwUwAQ#v=onepage&q&f=false

引用 2011-3-1 02:09 AM

fancao: what a joke!

接着漫人提到的台儿庄后面，作者写道：

These Atrocities Explain Jap Defeat

These ten pictures are not pretty to look at, but they partially explain why Japan is now being beaten at war. They were taken after the Japanese occupation of Nanking, Dec. 13. The photographer was an American missionary whose name must be concealed. He used a 16-mm. amateur movie camera carefully hidden from Japanese eyes.

The most dreadful pictures of the rape of Nanking this amateur photographer could not take. He knew that if he filmed civilians being shot down or houses looted and burned, he would be arrested and his camera smashed. Besides, he was too busy, like other foreign missionaries and doctors, saving what civilians he could. But for two weeks he saw an army completely out of control, raping, burning(?), killing, robbing and destroying without check. …. In foreign hospitals in and around Nanking he saw hundreds of innocent victims of “totalitarian war.”

But the rape of Nanking had, for the Japanese, its own devastating revenge. It 1) solidified China into an indomitable will to resist the invader; 2) so demoralized Japanese military discipline that they are now, to the world’s amazement, enduring some smashing defeat after another on the 1,000 mile Shangtung front.

我想，在这以前，日军是如入无人之境。在这以后，日军开始遇到抵抗了。虽然国军还是打不过，但也要打了。我们学的这个时期的历史，和真实出入太多。

另外，有些日本人还想说南京大屠杀是编出来的。这里的照片和文字可证明确有其事。

引用 2011-3-1 02:05 AM

正面报道有利军心。 有如现在党国如何民主国军如何伟大的“考古”论证一样。

引用 2011-3-1 12:33 AM

SevenStar: 哈哈，标准的政府宣传。

1938年正是皇军长驱直入，国军节节败退的典型年度。

元帅这次可放了歪炮。

去看了一哈原文，说的是台儿庄战役大捷，顺便提到了八路军（8th Route Army，嘿嘿）攻到了北京（！Peking）附近。由此引出战争相持阶段，并预言中国在持久战中的机会更大一点。虽然随后战局的发展并没有那么乐观，但结果差不多啦。38年的时候，好像米国还在为日本提供原油和其他原料吧，比如说橡胶5的？因此文章的表述，也是比较中性的，但可以看出倾向。

引用 2011-2-28 11:42 PM

what a joke!

引用 2011-2-28 11:32 PM

哈哈，标准的政府宣传。

1938年正是皇军长驱直入，国军节节败退的典型年度。

查看全部评论(8)